========================================================================= 
Log Path: /Users/k.seng/Library/CloudStorage/Dropbox/Social_expenditure/Data/log/libcode.log 
Program Path: /Users/k.seng/Library/CloudStorage/Dropbox/Social_expenditure/Data/libcode.R 
Working Directory: /Users/k.seng/Library/CloudStorage/Dropbox/Social_expenditure/Data 
User Name: k.seng 
R Version: 4.3.0 (2023-04-21) 
Machine: 5015B-1217 x86_64 
Operating System: Darwin 21.6.0 Darwin Kernel Version 21.6.0: Thu Mar 9 20:08:59 PST 2023; root:xnu-8020.240.18.700.8~1/RELEASE_X86_64 
Base Packages: stats graphics grDevices utils datasets methods base Other Packages: logr_1.3.3 sjPlot_2.8.14 lmerTest_3.1-3 lme4_1.1-33 Matrix_1.5-4 vtable_1.4.4 kableExtra_1.3.4 stargazer_5.2.3 
Log Start Time: 2023-06-05 23:27:29.379309 
========================================================================= 

Replication code: Parties and (de)liberalization 

NOTE: Log Print Time:  2023-06-05 23:27:29.385689 
NOTE: Elapsed Time: 0.00181913375854492 secs 

   year   country countryn cabinet_name govern        lib     delib    libtax delibtax
1  1973 Australia        1    Whitlam I    108  1.0000000 4.6666667        NA       NA
2  1974 Australia        1    Whitlam I    108  3.3333333 4.3333333 0.3333333        0
3  1975 Australia        1   Whitlam II    109  0.0000000 3.3333333        NA       NA
4  1976 Australia        1    Fraser II    110  1.3333334 6.3333333 0.0000000        1
5  1977 Australia        1    Fraser II    110  0.3333333 1.6666667        NA       NA
6  1978 Australia        1   Fraser III    111  3.0000000 0.0000000 0.3333333        0
7  1979 Australia        1   Fraser III    111  2.3333333 0.0000000        NA       NA
8  1980 Australia        1   Fraser III    111  2.3333333 0.0000000        NA       NA
9  1981 Australia        1    Fraser IV    112  1.6666667 0.0000000 0.3333333        0
10 1982 Australia        1    Fraser IV    112  1.3333333 0.0000000        NA       NA
11 1983 Australia        1    Fraser IV    112  4.0000000 5.0000000        NA       NA
12 1984 Australia        1      Hawke I    113  1.0000000 0.0000000 1.0000000        0
13 1985 Australia        1     Hawke II    114  2.0000000 2.0000000 1.0000000        2
14 1986 Australia        1     Hawke II    114  1.0000000 0.6666667        NA       NA
15 1987 Australia        1     Hawke II    114  6.0000001 1.0000000 1.0000000        0
16 1988 Australia        1    Hawke III    115  6.3333334 1.3333333        NA       NA
17 1989 Australia        1    Hawke III    115  2.3333333 2.0000000 0.0000000        1
18 1990 Australia        1    Hawke III    115  4.6666667 1.3333333        NA       NA
19 1991 Australia        1     Hawke IV    116  3.3333334 1.3333333        NA       NA
20 1992 Australia        1    Keating I    117  3.0000001 2.3333333        NA       NA
21 1993 Australia        1    Keating I    117  1.0000000 1.0000000        NA       NA
22 1994 Australia        1   Keating II    118  6.6666667 3.0000000        NA       NA
23 1995 Australia        1   Keating II    118  1.3333333 1.6666667        NA       NA
24 1996 Australia        1   Keating II    118 12.0000001 0.0000000        NA       NA
25 1997 Australia        1     Howard I    119  5.6666667 0.3333333        NA       NA
26 1998 Australia        1     Howard I    119  5.0000001 0.3333333        NA       NA
27 1999 Australia        1    Howard II    120  5.6666667 0.3333333 4.6666667        0
   libepl delibepl    libneb  delibneb    libpri delibpri instcons vturn duration
1      NA       NA        NA        NA        NA       NA        3  95.4      540
2      NA       NA        NA        NA        NA       NA        3  95.4      540
3      NA       NA        NA        NA        NA       NA        3  95.4      517
4      NA       NA 0.6666667 1.0000000        NA       NA        3  95.4      729
5      NA       NA        NA        NA        NA       NA        3  95.0      729
6      NA       NA        NA        NA        NA       NA        3  95.0     1049
7      NA       NA 1.0000000 0.0000000        NA       NA        3  95.0     1049
8      NA       NA 0.3333333 0.0000000        NA       NA        3  94.4     1049
9      NA       NA        NA        NA        NA       NA        3  94.4      858
10     NA       NA 0.3333333 0.0000000        NA       NA        3  94.4      858
11     NA       NA        NA        NA        NA       NA        3  94.6      858
12     NA       NA        NA        NA        NA       NA        3  94.2      643
13     NA       NA        NA        NA        NA       NA        3  94.2      953
14     NA       NA 0.3333333 0.0000000 0.3333333        0        3  94.2      953
15      0        1 1.0000000 0.0000000 1.3333333        0        3  93.8      953
16     NA       NA 1.0000000 0.0000000 0.6666667        0        3  93.8      985
17     NA       NA        NA        NA        NA       NA        3  93.8      985
18     NA       NA        NA        NA 1.0000000        0        3  95.3      985
19     NA       NA        NA        NA 0.3333333        0        3  95.3      625
20     NA       NA 0.0000000 0.3333333 1.6666667        0        3  95.3      460
21      0        1        NA        NA 0.6666667        0        3  95.8      460
22      0        1 0.3333333 0.0000000 1.0000000        0        3  95.8     1083
23     NA       NA 0.0000000 0.3333333        NA       NA        3  95.8     1083
24      1        0        NA        NA 6.0000001        0        3  95.8     1083
25     NA       NA        NA        NA 0.6666667        0        3  95.8      954
26     NA       NA        NA        NA 1.6666667        0        3  95.0      954
27     NA       NA        NA        NA        NA       NA        3  95.0     1132
   succession    openc     unemp   elderly deindust    ud     debt      deficit gdp_head
1           1 26.40824  2.308813  8.505940 56.98216 47.20       NA  1.119213462 18.15127
2           1 29.05620  2.670263  8.607410 58.19152 48.80       NA  0.479742527 17.37163
3           1 26.92904  4.902879  8.720712 59.82187 50.10       NA -1.456215620 17.46695
4           0 28.70572  4.773363  8.927668 60.57837 49.50       NA -1.492052555 18.02172
5           0 28.25451  5.631399  9.072448 60.91699 48.70       NA -1.835871458 18.13420
6           1 29.70571  6.397359  9.240117 62.41936 49.20       NA -2.313775063 18.81487
7           1 32.37457  6.264902  9.436164 61.89221 49.60       NA -0.745305479 19.22509
8           1 31.64659  6.105153  9.617167 62.61666 49.60       NA  0.165112019 19.63882
9           1 30.38132  5.783625  9.749874 63.00985 49.10       NA  0.008915126 20.26909
10          1 29.24065  7.162636  9.870545 63.69554 49.40       NA -0.846015453 19.48834
11          1 28.56795  9.961379  9.976697 64.75809 49.80       NA -1.817260146 20.38176
12          1 32.53518  8.986804 10.101720 65.60049 49.10       NA -1.387387753 20.93236
13          1 33.13704  8.258136 10.267270 66.46584 49.10       NA -0.926349163 21.28584
14          1 32.63861  8.080571 10.501150 66.84647 48.60       NA  0.209804535 21.48776
15          1 32.59515  8.106395 10.694170 67.98962 48.00       NA  1.780351281 22.89690
16          1 32.08442  7.225808 10.835740 67.59174 46.50       NA  3.148524761 23.99678
17          1 32.18307  6.174988 10.981620 68.34531 45.30 23.21602  2.076668739 24.47272
18          1 32.21466  6.925964 11.095030 69.03965 45.40 22.01100  0.762952805 24.10454
19          1 33.02927  9.579211 11.286220 70.90907 46.60 23.38117 -1.836896300 23.77175
20          1 35.30597 10.728770 11.453740 71.17899 43.70 27.69489 -2.763885975 24.52029
21          1 36.33454 10.873770 11.641620 70.76598 41.90 30.88878 -2.067256451 25.10500
22          1 37.65914  9.718678 11.794440 71.19379 37.60 40.33442 -1.150810838 26.10800
23          1 38.15935  8.469256 11.902250 73.06480 34.80 41.99136 -0.528123736 27.24274
24          1 37.91756  8.506213 12.027440 73.42233 34.40 39.23249  0.357909948 28.23920
25          1 39.92110  8.362230 12.142430 73.61682 29.29 37.50444  1.438788772 29.16052
26          1 38.88667  7.675598 12.247420 74.03654 27.45 32.40620  2.987176180 29.89991
27          1 40.77536  6.872334 12.343190 74.32326 24.90 27.97048  3.346333742 31.05475
    realgdpgr  inflation  cs1         cs2  gov_left soci chri      cons cabinet_econ
1   4.3908420  9.0909090 1973  0.00000000 100.00000    1    0 0.0000000     58.75758
2   1.5814749 15.4166670 1974  0.00147929 100.00000    1    0 0.0000000     30.00000
3   2.3548110 15.1624546 1975  0.01183432  86.30000    1    0 0.0000000     26.01576
4   3.9224195 13.3228836 1976  0.03994083   0.00000    0    0 0.7472528     26.01576
5   1.4483082 12.3098202 1977  0.09467456   0.00000    0    0 0.7472528     73.32980
6   2.0289249  8.0049257 1978  0.18491124   0.00000    0    0 0.7790698     73.32980
7   4.6479897  9.1220064 1979  0.31952661   0.00000    0    0 0.7790698     72.00753
8   2.8407924 10.1358414 1980  0.50739646   0.00000    0    0 0.7790698     72.00753
9   4.0732174  9.4876661 1981  0.75739646  27.03333    0    0 0.7297297     61.72973
10 -0.3931357 11.3518200 1982  1.07840240  27.03333    0    0 0.7297297     61.72973
11 -0.1760829 10.0389109 1983  1.47928989  27.03333    0    0 0.7297297     61.72973
12  6.5640588  3.9603961 1984  1.96893489 100.00000    1    0 0.0000000     36.00000
13  5.1573372  6.7346940 1985  2.55621290 100.00000    1    0 0.0000000     36.00000
14  2.3148525  9.0503502 1986  3.25000000 100.00000    1    0 0.0000000     61.99395
15  5.1571827  8.5330219 1987  4.05621290 100.00000    1    0 0.0000000     61.99395
16  4.3987670  7.2159395 1988  4.96893501 100.00000    1    0 0.0000000     42.99400
17  4.2669382  7.5339026 1989  5.97929001 100.00000    1    0 0.0000000     42.99400
18  1.5294884  7.3330221 1990  7.07840252 100.00000    1    0 0.0000000     42.99400
19 -1.1621791  3.1766753 1991  8.25739670 100.00000    1    0 0.0000000     51.99733
20  2.9330459  1.0122311 1992  9.50739670 100.00000    1    0 0.0000000     51.99733
21  4.0686183  1.7536534 1993 10.81952667 100.00000    1    0 0.0000000     51.99733
22  4.7623286  1.9696348 1994 12.18491077  73.04333    1    0 0.0000000     51.99733
23  3.5529931  4.6277666 1995 13.59467411  73.04333    1    0 0.0000000     41.98320
24  3.9231453  2.6153846 1996 15.03994083  73.04333    1    0 0.0000000     41.98320
25  3.9270353  0.2248875 1997 16.51183510   0.00000    0    0 0.8085107     51.05045
26  5.1442103  0.8601346 1998 18.00148010   0.00000    0    0 0.8085107     51.05045
27  4.0702291  1.4831294 1999 19.50000000   0.00000    0    0 0.8000000     51.05045
 [ reached 'max' / getOption("max.print") -- omitted 768 rows ]

NOTE: Data frame has 795 rows and 36 columns. 

NOTE: Log Print Time:  2023-06-05 23:27:29.431704 
NOTE: Elapsed Time: 0.0460150241851807 secs 

Linear mixed model fit by REML ['lmerModLmerTest']
Formula: lib ~ instcons + vturn + duration + succession + openc + unemp +  
    elderly + deindust + ud + debt + deficit + gdp_head + realgdpgr +  
    inflation + cs1 + cs2 + gov_left + (1 | countryn) + (1 |      govern) + (1 | year)
   Data: libdata
REML criterion at convergence: 3761.585
Random effects:
 Groups   Name        Std.Dev.
 govern   (Intercept) 1.4565  
 year     (Intercept) 0.7227  
 countryn (Intercept) 0.7168  
 Residual             3.1322  
Number of obs: 690, groups:  govern, 253; year, 39; countryn, 23
Fixed Effects:
(Intercept)     instcons        vturn     duration   succession        openc  
 -4.108e+02   -2.676e-01    6.321e-03    8.972e-04   -4.401e-01   -1.346e-02  
      unemp      elderly     deindust           ud         debt      deficit  
  1.853e-01    2.587e-01   -4.098e-02   -7.866e-03    2.030e-02    1.095e-01  
   gdp_head    realgdpgr    inflation          cs1          cs2     gov_left  
  2.270e-02   -1.318e-01    7.085e-02    2.075e-01   -1.411e-01   -9.754e-03  

NOTE: Log Print Time:  2023-06-05 23:27:29.660741 
NOTE: Elapsed Time: 0.229037046432495 secs 

Linear mixed model fit by REML ['lmerModLmerTest']
Formula: lib ~ instcons + vturn + duration + succession + openc + unemp +  
    elderly + deindust + ud + debt + deficit + gdp_head + realgdpgr +  
    inflation + cs1 + cs2 + soci + (1 | countryn) + (1 | govern) +      (1 | year)
   Data: libdata
REML criterion at convergence: 3753.316
Random effects:
 Groups   Name        Std.Dev.
 govern   (Intercept) 1.4784  
 year     (Intercept) 0.7084  
 countryn (Intercept) 0.7440  
 Residual             3.1278  
Number of obs: 690, groups:  govern, 253; year, 39; countryn, 23
Fixed Effects:
(Intercept)     instcons        vturn     duration   succession        openc  
 -4.234e+02   -2.513e-01    3.353e-03    9.243e-04   -4.231e-01   -1.322e-02  
      unemp      elderly     deindust           ud         debt      deficit  
  1.779e-01    2.423e-01   -3.857e-02   -8.487e-03    2.111e-02    1.102e-01  
   gdp_head    realgdpgr    inflation          cs1          cs2         soci  
  1.714e-02   -1.299e-01    7.453e-02    2.139e-01   -1.448e-01   -8.053e-01  

NOTE: Log Print Time:  2023-06-05 23:27:29.880927 
NOTE: Elapsed Time: 0.220185995101929 secs 

Linear mixed model fit by REML ['lmerModLmerTest']
Formula: lib ~ instcons + vturn + duration + succession + openc + unemp +  
    elderly + deindust + ud + debt + deficit + gdp_head + realgdpgr +  
    inflation + cs1 + cs2 + chri + (1 | countryn) + (1 | govern) +      (1 | year)
   Data: libdata
REML criterion at convergence: 3754.68
Random effects:
 Groups   Name        Std.Dev.
 govern   (Intercept) 1.4977  
 year     (Intercept) 0.6861  
 countryn (Intercept) 0.8024  
 Residual             3.1281  
Number of obs: 690, groups:  govern, 253; year, 39; countryn, 23
Fixed Effects:
(Intercept)     instcons        vturn     duration   succession        openc  
 -4.309e+02   -1.941e-01    6.864e-03    8.573e-04   -5.595e-01   -1.081e-02  
      unemp      elderly     deindust           ud         debt      deficit  
  1.728e-01    2.087e-01   -4.253e-02   -9.752e-03    2.397e-02    1.062e-01  
   gdp_head    realgdpgr    inflation          cs1          cs2         chri  
  2.582e-02   -1.295e-01    7.733e-02    2.176e-01   -1.520e-01   -8.211e-01  
fit warnings:
Some predictor variables are on very different scales: consider rescaling

NOTE: Log Print Time:  2023-06-05 23:27:30.142321 
NOTE: Elapsed Time: 0.261394023895264 secs 

Linear mixed model fit by REML ['lmerModLmerTest']
Formula: lib ~ instcons + vturn + duration + succession + openc + unemp +  
    elderly + deindust + ud + debt + deficit + gdp_head + realgdpgr +  
    inflation + cs1 + cs2 + cabinet_econ + (1 | countryn) + (1 |  
    govern) + (1 | year)
   Data: libdata
REML criterion at convergence: 3763.922
Random effects:
 Groups   Name        Std.Dev.
 govern   (Intercept) 1.4973  
 year     (Intercept) 0.6875  
 countryn (Intercept) 0.8052  
 Residual             3.1307  
Number of obs: 690, groups:  govern, 253; year, 39; countryn, 23
Fixed Effects:
 (Intercept)      instcons         vturn      duration    succession         openc  
  -3.968e+02    -2.236e-01     2.041e-04     8.580e-04    -4.663e-01    -1.276e-02  
       unemp       elderly      deindust            ud          debt       deficit  
   1.795e-01     2.043e-01    -3.570e-02    -7.811e-03     2.269e-02     1.117e-01  
    gdp_head     realgdpgr     inflation           cs1           cs2  cabinet_econ  
   2.466e-02    -1.319e-01     7.478e-02     2.004e-01    -1.383e-01     6.391e-03  

NOTE: Log Print Time:  2023-06-05 23:27:30.367533 
NOTE: Elapsed Time: 0.22521185874939 secs 

Linear mixed model fit by REML ['lmerModLmerTest']
Formula: delib ~ instcons + vturn + duration + succession + openc + unemp +  
    elderly + deindust + debt + deficit + gdp_head + realgdpgr +  
    inflation + cs1 + cs2 + gov_left + (1 | countryn) + (1 |      govern) + (1 | year)
   Data: libdata
REML criterion at convergence: 3217.024
Random effects:
 Groups   Name        Std.Dev.
 govern   (Intercept) 0.5280  
 year     (Intercept) 0.1598  
 countryn (Intercept) 1.0012  
 Residual             2.0699  
Number of obs: 709, groups:  govern, 258; year, 39; countryn, 23
Fixed Effects:
(Intercept)     instcons        vturn     duration   succession        openc  
 93.6091182    0.1422471   -0.0356394    0.0005141   -0.5238226    0.0040718  
      unemp      elderly     deindust         debt      deficit     gdp_head  
 -0.0013452   -0.1213357    0.0072709    0.0048546   -0.0106331   -0.0472584  
  realgdpgr    inflation          cs1          cs2     gov_left  
  0.0029122    0.0317425   -0.0445912    0.0773820    0.0055838  

NOTE: Log Print Time:  2023-06-05 23:27:38.845198 
NOTE: Elapsed Time: 8.47766494750977 secs 

Linear mixed model fit by REML ['lmerModLmerTest']
Formula: delib ~ instcons + vturn + duration + succession + openc + unemp +  
    elderly + deindust + debt + deficit + gdp_head + realgdpgr +  
    inflation + cs1 + cs2 + soci + (1 | countryn) + (1 | govern) +      (1 | year)
   Data: libdata
REML criterion at convergence: 3207.444
Random effects:
 Groups   Name        Std.Dev.
 govern   (Intercept) 0.5232  
 year     (Intercept) 0.1616  
 countryn (Intercept) 0.9953  
 Residual             2.0702  
Number of obs: 709, groups:  govern, 258; year, 39; countryn, 23
Fixed Effects:
(Intercept)     instcons        vturn     duration   succession        openc  
  1.007e+02    1.353e-01   -3.466e-02    4.956e-04   -5.349e-01    4.033e-03  
      unemp      elderly     deindust         debt      deficit     gdp_head  
  3.104e-03   -1.117e-01    6.357e-03    4.330e-03   -9.706e-03   -4.410e-02  
  realgdpgr    inflation          cs1          cs2         soci  
  1.183e-03    3.018e-02   -4.826e-02    7.898e-02    5.413e-01  

NOTE: Log Print Time:  2023-06-05 23:27:39.078637 
NOTE: Elapsed Time: 0.233438968658447 secs 

Linear mixed model fit by REML ['lmerModLmerTest']
Formula: delib ~ instcons + vturn + duration + succession + openc + unemp +  
    elderly + deindust + debt + deficit + gdp_head + realgdpgr +  
    inflation + cs1 + cs2 + chri + (1 | countryn) + (1 | govern) +      (1 | year)
   Data: libdata
REML criterion at convergence: 3211.688
Random effects:
 Groups   Name        Std.Dev.
 govern   (Intercept) 0.5634  
 year     (Intercept) 0.1738  
 countryn (Intercept) 1.0051  
 Residual             2.0692  
Number of obs: 709, groups:  govern, 258; year, 39; countryn, 23
Fixed Effects:
(Intercept)     instcons        vturn     duration   succession        openc  
 99.5675091    0.1350048   -0.0348326    0.0005334   -0.5014057    0.0037524  
      unemp      elderly     deindust         debt      deficit     gdp_head  
  0.0046914   -0.1041611    0.0049368    0.0039220   -0.0074397   -0.0494310  
  realgdpgr    inflation          cs1          cs2         chri  
  0.0005874    0.0298292   -0.0475415    0.0811130    0.0230068  
fit warnings:
Some predictor variables are on very different scales: consider rescaling

NOTE: Log Print Time:  2023-06-05 23:27:39.299113 
NOTE: Elapsed Time: 0.220476150512695 secs 

Linear mixed model fit by REML ['lmerModLmerTest']
Formula: delib ~ instcons + vturn + duration + succession + openc + unemp +  
    elderly + deindust + debt + deficit + gdp_head + realgdpgr +  
    inflation + cs1 + cs2 + cabinet_econ + (1 | countryn) + (1 |  
    govern) + (1 | year)
   Data: libdata
REML criterion at convergence: 3219.745
Random effects:
 Groups   Name        Std.Dev.
 govern   (Intercept) 0.5620  
 year     (Intercept) 0.1738  
 countryn (Intercept) 0.9999  
 Residual             2.0697  
Number of obs: 709, groups:  govern, 258; year, 39; countryn, 23
Fixed Effects:
 (Intercept)      instcons         vturn      duration    succession         openc  
  96.4521693     0.1341682    -0.0344106     0.0005343    -0.5064135     0.0038034  
       unemp       elderly      deindust          debt       deficit      gdp_head  
   0.0044033    -0.1027400     0.0047999     0.0039463    -0.0077696    -0.0496092  
   realgdpgr     inflation           cs1           cs2  cabinet_econ  
   0.0008876     0.0297280    -0.0459606     0.0800048    -0.0011051  

NOTE: Log Print Time:  2023-06-05 23:27:39.530653 
NOTE: Elapsed Time: 0.231539964675903 secs 


NOTE: Log Print Time:  2023-06-05 23:27:48.086307 
NOTE: Elapsed Time: 8.55565404891968 secs 

   year   country countryn cabinet_name govern       lib     delib    libtax delibtax
1  1973 Australia        1    Whitlam I    108 1.0000000 4.6666667        NA       NA
2  1974 Australia        1    Whitlam I    108 3.3333333 4.3333333 0.3333333        0
3  1975 Australia        1   Whitlam II    109 0.0000000 3.3333333        NA       NA
4  1976 Australia        1    Fraser II    110 1.3333334 6.3333333 0.0000000        1
5  1977 Australia        1    Fraser II    110 0.3333333 1.6666667        NA       NA
6  1978 Australia        1   Fraser III    111 3.0000000 0.0000000 0.3333333        0
7  1979 Australia        1   Fraser III    111 2.3333333 0.0000000        NA       NA
8  1980 Australia        1   Fraser III    111 2.3333333 0.0000000        NA       NA
9  1981 Australia        1    Fraser IV    112 1.6666667 0.0000000 0.3333333        0
10 1982 Australia        1    Fraser IV    112 1.3333333 0.0000000        NA       NA
11 1983 Australia        1    Fraser IV    112 4.0000000 5.0000000        NA       NA
12 1984 Australia        1      Hawke I    113 1.0000000 0.0000000 1.0000000        0
13 1985 Australia        1     Hawke II    114 2.0000000 2.0000000 1.0000000        2
14 1986 Australia        1     Hawke II    114 1.0000000 0.6666667        NA       NA
15 1987 Australia        1     Hawke II    114 6.0000001 1.0000000 1.0000000        0
16 1988 Australia        1    Hawke III    115 6.3333334 1.3333333        NA       NA
17 1989 Australia        1    Hawke III    115 2.3333333 2.0000000 0.0000000        1
18 1990 Australia        1    Hawke III    115 4.6666667 1.3333333        NA       NA
19 1991 Australia        1     Hawke IV    116 3.3333334 1.3333333        NA       NA
20 1992 Australia        1    Keating I    117 3.0000001 2.3333333        NA       NA
41 1973   Austria        2   Kreisky II    207 0.0000000 0.3333333        NA       NA
42 1974   Austria        2   Kreisky II    207 0.0000000 0.3333333        NA       NA
43 1975   Austria        2   Kreisky II    207 0.3333333 0.3333333 0.3333333        0
44 1976   Austria        2  Kreisky III    208 1.3333333 0.0000000        NA       NA
45 1977   Austria        2  Kreisky III    208 0.6666667 0.3333333 0.3333333        0
46 1978   Austria        2  Kreisky III    208 0.0000000 0.0000000        NA       NA
47 1979   Austria        2  Kreisky III    208 1.0000000 0.0000000 0.6666667        0
   libepl delibepl    libneb  delibneb    libpri delibpri instcons vturn duration
1      NA       NA        NA        NA        NA       NA        3  95.4      540
2      NA       NA        NA        NA        NA       NA        3  95.4      540
3      NA       NA        NA        NA        NA       NA        3  95.4      517
4      NA       NA 0.6666667 1.0000000        NA       NA        3  95.4      729
5      NA       NA        NA        NA        NA       NA        3  95.0      729
6      NA       NA        NA        NA        NA       NA        3  95.0     1049
7      NA       NA 1.0000000 0.0000000        NA       NA        3  95.0     1049
8      NA       NA 0.3333333 0.0000000        NA       NA        3  94.4     1049
9      NA       NA        NA        NA        NA       NA        3  94.4      858
10     NA       NA 0.3333333 0.0000000        NA       NA        3  94.4      858
11     NA       NA        NA        NA        NA       NA        3  94.6      858
12     NA       NA        NA        NA        NA       NA        3  94.2      643
13     NA       NA        NA        NA        NA       NA        3  94.2      953
14     NA       NA 0.3333333 0.0000000 0.3333333        0        3  94.2      953
15      0        1 1.0000000 0.0000000 1.3333333        0        3  93.8      953
16     NA       NA 1.0000000 0.0000000 0.6666667        0        3  93.8      985
17     NA       NA        NA        NA        NA       NA        3  93.8      985
18     NA       NA        NA        NA 1.0000000        0        3  95.3      985
19     NA       NA        NA        NA 0.3333333        0        3  95.3      625
20     NA       NA 0.0000000 0.3333333 1.6666667        0        3  95.3      460
41     NA       NA        NA        NA        NA       NA        2  92.4     1454
42     NA       NA        NA        NA        NA       NA        2  92.4     1454
43     NA       NA 0.0000000 0.3333333        NA       NA        2  92.9     1454
44     NA       NA        NA        NA        NA       NA        2  92.9     1316
45     NA       NA 0.0000000 0.3333333        NA       NA        2  92.9     1316
46     NA       NA        NA        NA        NA       NA        2  92.9     1316
47     NA       NA        NA        NA        NA       NA        2  92.2     1316
   succession    openc     unemp   elderly deindust   ud     debt      deficit gdp_head
1           1 26.40824  2.308813  8.505940 56.98216 47.2       NA  1.119213462 18.15127
2           1 29.05620  2.670263  8.607410 58.19152 48.8       NA  0.479742527 17.37163
3           1 26.92904  4.902879  8.720712 59.82187 50.1       NA -1.456215620 17.46695
4           0 28.70572  4.773363  8.927668 60.57837 49.5       NA -1.492052555 18.02172
5           0 28.25451  5.631399  9.072448 60.91699 48.7       NA -1.835871458 18.13420
6           1 29.70571  6.397359  9.240117 62.41936 49.2       NA -2.313775063 18.81487
7           1 32.37457  6.264902  9.436164 61.89221 49.6       NA -0.745305479 19.22509
8           1 31.64659  6.105153  9.617167 62.61666 49.6       NA  0.165112019 19.63882
9           1 30.38132  5.783625  9.749874 63.00985 49.1       NA  0.008915126 20.26909
10          1 29.24065  7.162636  9.870545 63.69554 49.4       NA -0.846015453 19.48834
11          1 28.56795  9.961379  9.976697 64.75809 49.8       NA -1.817260146 20.38176
12          1 32.53518  8.986804 10.101720 65.60049 49.1       NA -1.387387753 20.93236
13          1 33.13704  8.258136 10.267270 66.46584 49.1       NA -0.926349163 21.28584
14          1 32.63861  8.080571 10.501150 66.84647 48.6       NA  0.209804535 21.48776
15          1 32.59515  8.106395 10.694170 67.98962 48.0       NA  1.780351281 22.89690
16          1 32.08442  7.225808 10.835740 67.59174 46.5       NA  3.148524761 23.99678
17          1 32.18307  6.174988 10.981620 68.34531 45.3 23.21602  2.076668739 24.47272
18          1 32.21466  6.925964 11.095030 69.03965 45.4 22.01100  0.762952805 24.10454
19          1 33.02927  9.579211 11.286220 70.90907 46.6 23.38117 -1.836896300 23.77175
20          1 35.30597 10.728770 11.453740 71.17899 43.7 27.69489 -2.763885975 24.52029
41          1 56.34431  1.084456 14.473840 42.65781 60.8 16.74426  1.714880109 13.59979
42          1 61.62965  1.343822 14.652950 45.98007 57.9 16.86910  1.728193283 14.03975
43          1 58.56184  1.769616 14.871090 46.53297 59.0 22.92002 -1.846988082 14.09581
44          1 61.98589  1.799400 15.040210 47.57380 59.2 26.27228 -2.832373381 14.41155
45          1 62.35168  1.612903 15.191510 47.60789 58.6 28.58036 -1.346684813 15.00474
46          1 61.73298  2.078597 15.341340 48.45771 57.6 32.25391 -1.713487864 14.93789
47          1 65.50838  2.086008 15.451670 48.90200 56.7 34.23886 -1.393804550 15.54983
    realgdpgr inflation  cs1        cs2  gov_left soci chri      cons cabinet_econ
1   4.3908420  9.090909 1973 0.00000000 100.00000    1    0 0.0000000     58.75758
2   1.5814749 15.416667 1974 0.00147929 100.00000    1    0 0.0000000     30.00000
3   2.3548110 15.162455 1975 0.01183432  86.30000    1    0 0.0000000     26.01576
4   3.9224195 13.322884 1976 0.03994083   0.00000    0    0 0.7472528     26.01576
5   1.4483082 12.309820 1977 0.09467456   0.00000    0    0 0.7472528     73.32980
6   2.0289249  8.004926 1978 0.18491124   0.00000    0    0 0.7790698     73.32980
7   4.6479897  9.122006 1979 0.31952661   0.00000    0    0 0.7790698     72.00753
8   2.8407924 10.135841 1980 0.50739646   0.00000    0    0 0.7790698     72.00753
9   4.0732174  9.487666 1981 0.75739646  27.03333    0    0 0.7297297     61.72973
10 -0.3931357 11.351820 1982 1.07840240  27.03333    0    0 0.7297297     61.72973
11 -0.1760829 10.038911 1983 1.47928989  27.03333    0    0 0.7297297     61.72973
12  6.5640588  3.960396 1984 1.96893489 100.00000    1    0 0.0000000     36.00000
13  5.1573372  6.734694 1985 2.55621290 100.00000    1    0 0.0000000     36.00000
14  2.3148525  9.050350 1986 3.25000000 100.00000    1    0 0.0000000     61.99395
15  5.1571827  8.533022 1987 4.05621290 100.00000    1    0 0.0000000     61.99395
16  4.3987670  7.215940 1988 4.96893501 100.00000    1    0 0.0000000     42.99400
17  4.2669382  7.533903 1989 5.97929001 100.00000    1    0 0.0000000     42.99400
18  1.5294884  7.333022 1990 7.07840252 100.00000    1    0 0.0000000     42.99400
19 -1.1621791  3.176675 1991 8.25739670 100.00000    1    0 0.0000000     51.99733
20  2.9330459  1.012231 1992 9.50739670 100.00000    1    0 0.0000000     51.99733
41  4.8867879  7.531081 1973 0.00000000 100.00000    1    0 0.0000000     34.24903
42  3.9434950  9.521791 1974 0.00147929 100.00000    1    0 0.0000000     34.24903
43 -0.3625287  8.445255 1975 0.01183432 100.00000    1    0 0.0000000     34.24903
44  4.5767522  7.318689 1976 0.03994083 100.00000    1    0 0.0000000     32.44645
45  4.6768069  5.494610 1977 0.09467456 100.00000    1    0 0.0000000     32.44645
46 -0.3623567  3.574322 1978 0.18491124 100.00000    1    0 0.0000000     32.44645
47  5.4545703  3.707406 1979 0.31952661 100.00000    1    0 0.0000000     32.44645
 [ reached 'max' / getOption("max.print") -- omitted 354 rows ]

NOTE: Data frame has 381 rows and 36 columns. 

NOTE: Log Print Time:  2023-06-05 23:27:48.110313 
NOTE: Elapsed Time: 0.0240058898925781 secs 

   year   country countryn  cabinet_name govern        lib     delib    libtax  delibtax
21 1993 Australia        1     Keating I    117  1.0000000 1.0000000        NA        NA
22 1994 Australia        1    Keating II    118  6.6666667 3.0000000        NA        NA
23 1995 Australia        1    Keating II    118  1.3333333 1.6666667        NA        NA
24 1996 Australia        1    Keating II    118 12.0000001 0.0000000        NA        NA
25 1997 Australia        1      Howard I    119  5.6666667 0.3333333        NA        NA
26 1998 Australia        1      Howard I    119  5.0000001 0.3333333        NA        NA
27 1999 Australia        1     Howard II    120  5.6666667 0.3333333 4.6666667 0.0000000
28 2000 Australia        1     Howard II    120  1.6666667 0.0000000        NA        NA
29 2001 Australia        1     Howard II    120  5.6666667 0.0000000        NA        NA
30 2002 Australia        1    Howard III    121  0.0000000 0.0000000        NA        NA
31 2003 Australia        1    Howard III    121  2.6666667 0.3333333 1.0000000 0.0000000
32 2004 Australia        1    Howard III    121  1.3333334 4.6666667        NA        NA
33 2005 Australia        1     Howard IV    122  6.0000000 1.0000000        NA        NA
34 2006 Australia        1     Howard IV    122  0.6666667 0.0000000 0.3333333 0.0000000
35 2007 Australia        1     Howard IV    122  2.0000000 0.0000000 0.3333333 0.0000000
36 2008 Australia        1        Rudd I    123  0.3333333 1.0000000        NA        NA
37 2009 Australia        1        Rudd I    123  2.3333334 3.3333334        NA        NA
38 2010 Australia        1        Rudd I    123  1.6666667 0.0000000        NA        NA
39 2011 Australia        1    Gillard II    124  1.3333333 0.6666667        NA        NA
40 2012 Australia        1    Gillard II    124  1.3333334 1.3333333 0.0000000 1.0000000
60 1993   Austria        2 Vranitzky III    212  5.0000001 1.3333333 0.6666667 0.0000000
61 1994   Austria        2 Vranitzky III    212  2.6666667 1.3333334 1.3333333 0.6666667
62 1995   Austria        2  Vranitzky IV    213  4.0000001 1.0000000        NA        NA
63 1996   Austria        2  Vranitzky IV    213  3.0000000 0.6666667        NA        NA
64 1998   Austria        2       Klima I    214  3.6666667 0.3333333        NA        NA
65 1999   Austria        2       Klima I    214  2.3333334 0.3333333        NA        NA
66 2001   Austria        2   Schuessel I    215  5.3333334 1.0000000        NA        NA
      libepl  delibepl    libneb  delibneb    libpri delibpri instcons vturn duration
21 0.0000000 1.0000000        NA        NA 0.6666667        0        3  95.8      460
22 0.0000000 1.0000000 0.3333333 0.0000000 1.0000000        0        3  95.8     1083
23        NA        NA 0.0000000 0.3333333        NA       NA        3  95.8     1083
24 1.0000000 0.0000000        NA        NA 6.0000001        0        3  95.8     1083
25        NA        NA        NA        NA 0.6666667        0        3  95.8      954
26        NA        NA        NA        NA 1.6666667        0        3  95.0      954
27        NA        NA        NA        NA        NA       NA        3  95.0     1132
28        NA        NA        NA        NA 1.3333334        0        3  95.0     1132
29 0.3333333 0.0000000 1.6666667 0.0000000 0.3333333        0        3  94.9     1132
30        NA        NA        NA        NA        NA       NA        3  94.9     1065
31        NA        NA        NA        NA        NA       NA        3  94.9     1065
32        NA        NA 0.3333333 0.0000000 0.3333333        0        3  94.3     1065
33 1.0000000 0.0000000        NA        NA        NA       NA        3  94.3     1133
34        NA        NA        NA        NA        NA       NA        3  94.3     1133
35        NA        NA 1.3333333 0.0000000        NA       NA        3  94.8     1133
36        NA        NA        NA        NA        NA       NA        3  94.8      934
37 0.0000000 0.3333333 0.6666667 0.0000000        NA       NA        3  94.8      934
38        NA        NA 0.3333333 0.0000000        NA       NA        3  93.2      934
39        NA        NA        NA        NA        NA       NA        3  93.2     1017
40        NA        NA 0.3333333 0.0000000        NA       NA        3  93.2     1017
60 0.0000000 1.3333333 1.0000000 0.0000000        NA       NA        2  83.7     1443
61        NA        NA 0.0000000 0.3333333 0.3333333        0        2  81.9     1443
62        NA        NA 2.3333334 0.3333333 0.3333333        0        3  86.0      469
63 0.0000000 0.3333333 0.3333333 0.0000000        NA       NA        3  86.0      469
64        NA        NA 0.3333333 0.0000000        NA       NA        3  86.0      978
65        NA        NA        NA        NA        NA       NA        4  80.4      978
66 0.3333333 0.0000000 0.6666667 0.3333333 0.3333333        0        4  80.4     1024
   succession    openc     unemp  elderly deindust    ud     debt    deficit gdp_head
21          1 36.33454 10.873770 11.64162 70.76598 41.90 30.88878 -2.0672565 25.10500
22          1 37.65914  9.718678 11.79444 71.19379 37.60 40.33442 -1.1508108 26.10800
23          1 38.15935  8.469256 11.90225 73.06480 34.80 41.99136 -0.5281237 27.24274
24          1 37.91756  8.506213 12.02744 73.42233 34.40 39.23249  0.3579099 28.23920
25          1 39.92110  8.362230 12.14243 73.61682 29.29 37.50444  1.4387888 29.16052
26          1 38.88667  7.675598 12.24742 74.03654 27.45 32.40620  2.9871762 29.89991
27          1 40.77536  6.872334 12.34319 74.32326 24.90 27.97048  3.3463337 31.05475
28          1 43.94571  6.282619 12.42314 74.48873 24.49 24.96393  2.1290772 31.74611
29          1 41.21648  6.742314 12.54994 75.41498 24.20 22.09860  0.3468178 32.42515
30          1 39.91380  6.367617 12.64940 75.54791 22.90 20.07904  1.6090504 33.09565
31          1 36.67385  5.928698 12.73262 76.00658 22.69 18.59079  2.2193370 34.08530
32          1 38.76147  5.394726 12.83801 76.33759 21.89 16.85077  2.0057976 34.47176
33          1 40.87010  5.032480 12.94543 76.69773 21.91 16.41467  2.1312366 36.24002
34          1 41.13318  4.782292 13.02626 76.69914 19.84 15.65708  2.2378848 36.25402
35          1 41.83676  4.376975 13.14096 76.84057 18.19 14.61735  1.6470461 36.55966
36          1 44.86351  4.234151 13.20062 76.57124 18.24 13.91612 -0.8204466 35.84682
37          1 39.59741  5.560666 13.32749 77.29868 18.96 19.48450 -4.8531327 36.06839
38          1 41.06392  5.211326 13.55755 77.42036    NA 23.63712 -4.7455521 36.26144
39          0 42.77044  5.080750 13.82274 77.92041    NA 27.12922 -3.1574175 36.69543
40          0       NA  5.219909 14.16124 77.94543    NA 32.38514 -2.9673607       NA
60          1 65.45940  4.258168 14.92583 57.93007 43.20 61.93698 -1.2923309 23.17619
61          1 68.27045  3.587211 15.01070 59.34214 41.40 65.18257 -2.0388801 24.20488
62          1 70.62069  3.718048 15.12837 60.28426 41.10 69.36359 -2.5369592 25.59873
63          1 72.53059  4.167752 15.23093 59.98913 40.10 70.08318 -0.7164826 25.79498
64          0 81.20517  4.281266 15.38168 63.02521 38.40 68.04246  0.6020746 27.74917
65          0 82.92865  3.791591 15.41090 63.24397 37.40 70.95586  0.4198064 28.84608
66          0 93.96218  3.661034 15.46345 64.36354 35.70 71.60816  2.4721487 30.01673
   realgdpgr inflation  cs1      cs2  gov_left      soci      chri      cons cabinet_econ
21 4.0686183 1.7536534 1993 10.81953 100.00000 1.0000000 0.0000000 0.0000000     51.99733
22 4.7623286 1.9696348 1994 12.18491  73.04333 1.0000000 0.0000000 0.0000000     51.99733
23 3.5529931 4.6277666 1995 13.59467  73.04333 1.0000000 0.0000000 0.0000000     41.98320
24 3.9231453 2.6153846 1996 15.03994  73.04333 1.0000000 0.0000000 0.0000000     41.98320
25 3.9270353 0.2248875 1997 16.51184   0.00000 0.0000000 0.0000000 0.8085107     51.05045
26 5.1442103 0.8601346 1998 18.00148   0.00000 0.0000000 0.0000000 0.8085107     51.05045
27 4.0702291 1.4831294 1999 19.50000   0.00000 0.0000000 0.0000000 0.8000000     51.05045
28 3.1782677 4.4574351 2000 21.00000   0.00000 0.0000000 0.0000000 0.8000000     69.93000
29 2.6913695 4.4071355 2001 22.50000   0.00000 0.0000000 0.0000000 0.8000000     69.93000
30 3.8977199 2.9815745 2002 24.00000   0.00000 0.0000000 0.0000000 0.8414634     64.48888
31 3.2607443 2.7325959 2003 25.50000   0.00000 0.0000000 0.0000000 0.8414634     64.48888
32 3.7807980 2.3432553 2004 27.00000   0.00000 0.0000000 0.0000000 0.8414634     64.48888
33 3.2729881 2.6918316 2005 28.50000   2.65000 0.0000000 0.0000000 0.8620690     77.86047
34 2.6284378 3.5552878 2006 30.00000   2.65000 0.0000000 0.0000000 0.8620690     77.86047
35 4.8356147 2.3276112 2007 31.50000   2.65000 0.0000000 0.0000000 0.8620690     77.86047
36 2.4433708 4.3502984 2008 33.00000 100.00000 1.0000000 0.0000000 0.0000000     50.96928
37 1.4968294 1.7711172 2009 34.50000 100.00000 1.0000000 0.0000000 0.0000000     50.96928
38 2.5849562 2.9183400 2010 36.00000 100.00000 1.0000000 0.0000000 0.0000000     50.96928
39 2.4163120 3.3038502 2011 37.50000 100.00000 1.0000000 0.0000000 0.0000000     49.00000
40 3.6809609 1.7627802 2012 39.00000 100.00000 1.0000000 0.0000000 0.0000000     49.00000
60 0.8085306 3.6317856 1993 10.81953  57.08500 0.5714286 0.4285714 0.0000000     49.00217
61 2.4386849 2.9534066 1994 12.18491  57.08500 0.5714286 0.4285714 0.0000000     49.00217
62 2.8818905 2.2433639 1995 13.59467  56.43500 0.5555556 0.4444444 0.0000000     57.85772
63 2.0390329 1.8609741 1996 15.03994  56.43500 0.5555556 0.4444444 0.0000000     57.85772
64 3.7583497 0.9224669 1998 18.00148  57.74000 0.5725806 0.4274194 0.0000000     74.39619
65 3.4330249 0.5689865 1999 19.50000  57.74000 0.5725806 0.4274194 0.0000000     74.39619
66 0.9790634 2.6500001 2001 22.50000   0.00000 0.0000000 0.5000000 0.0000000     72.46096
 [ reached 'max' / getOption("max.print") -- omitted 387 rows ]

NOTE: Data frame has 414 rows and 36 columns. 

NOTE: Log Print Time:  2023-06-05 23:27:48.135434 
NOTE: Elapsed Time: 0.0251209735870361 secs 

Linear mixed model fit by REML ['lmerModLmerTest']
Formula: lib ~ instcons + vturn + duration + succession + openc + unemp +  
    elderly + deindust + ud + debt + deficit + gdp_head + realgdpgr +  
    inflation + cs1 + cs2 + gov_left + (1 | countryn) + (1 |      govern) + (1 | year)
   Data: libdata_73_92
REML criterion at convergence: 1635.301
Random effects:
 Groups   Name        Std.Dev.
 govern   (Intercept) 1.14320 
 countryn (Intercept) 0.63620 
 year     (Intercept) 0.00191 
 Residual             2.75852 
Number of obs: 312, groups:  govern, 129; countryn, 21; year, 20
Fixed Effects:
(Intercept)     instcons        vturn     duration   succession        openc  
 -1.206e+01   -1.077e-01    1.389e-02    6.828e-04    1.609e-01   -4.746e-02  
      unemp      elderly     deindust           ud         debt      deficit  
  4.846e-02    1.380e-01    8.049e-02   -3.562e-03    3.072e-02    1.252e-01  
   gdp_head    realgdpgr    inflation          cs1          cs2     gov_left  
 -2.274e-01   -8.751e-04    1.685e-01    4.852e-03    4.254e-01   -6.647e-03  

NOTE: Log Print Time:  2023-06-05 23:27:48.295237 
NOTE: Elapsed Time: 0.159803152084351 secs 

Linear mixed model fit by REML ['lmerModLmerTest']
Formula: lib ~ instcons + vturn + duration + succession + openc + unemp +  
    elderly + deindust + ud + debt + deficit + gdp_head + realgdpgr +  
    inflation + cs1 + cs2 + soci + (1 | countryn) + (1 | govern) +      (1 | year)
   Data: libdata_73_92
REML criterion at convergence: 1627.39
Random effects:
 Groups   Name        Std.Dev.
 govern   (Intercept) 1.1929  
 countryn (Intercept) 0.6029  
 year     (Intercept) 0.1322  
 Residual             2.7498  
Number of obs: 312, groups:  govern, 129; countryn, 21; year, 20
Fixed Effects:
(Intercept)     instcons        vturn     duration   succession        openc  
 -2.679e+01   -9.788e-02    9.368e-03    6.736e-04    1.526e-01   -4.723e-02  
      unemp      elderly     deindust           ud         debt      deficit  
  3.966e-02    1.165e-01    8.020e-02   -3.696e-03    3.346e-02    1.271e-01  
   gdp_head    realgdpgr    inflation          cs1          cs2         soci  
 -2.261e-01    2.960e-04    1.714e-01    1.248e-02    4.134e-01   -2.088e-01  

NOTE: Log Print Time:  2023-06-05 23:27:48.461039 
NOTE: Elapsed Time: 0.165802001953125 secs 

Linear mixed model fit by REML ['lmerModLmerTest']
Formula: lib ~ instcons + vturn + duration + succession + openc + unemp +  
    elderly + deindust + ud + debt + deficit + gdp_head + realgdpgr +  
    inflation + cs1 + cs2 + chri + (1 | countryn) + (1 | govern) +      (1 | year)
   Data: libdata_73_92
REML criterion at convergence: 1625.262
Random effects:
 Groups   Name        Std.Dev.
 govern   (Intercept) 1.1980  
 countryn (Intercept) 0.5307  
 year     (Intercept) 0.1705  
 Residual             2.7449  
Number of obs: 312, groups:  govern, 129; countryn, 21; year, 20
Fixed Effects:
(Intercept)     instcons        vturn     duration   succession        openc  
 -5.325e+01   -1.226e-01    2.710e-03    6.123e-04    2.541e-01   -4.919e-02  
      unemp      elderly     deindust           ud         debt      deficit  
  3.533e-02    9.698e-02    9.650e-02   -8.719e-04    3.013e-02    1.303e-01  
   gdp_head    realgdpgr    inflation          cs1          cs2         chri  
 -2.362e-01    3.003e-04    1.694e-01    2.587e-02    3.871e-01    9.916e-01  
fit warnings:
Some predictor variables are on very different scales: consider rescaling

NOTE: Log Print Time:  2023-06-05 23:27:48.649311 
NOTE: Elapsed Time: 0.188271999359131 secs 

Linear mixed model fit by REML ['lmerModLmerTest']
Formula: lib ~ instcons + vturn + duration + succession + openc + unemp +  
    elderly + deindust + ud + debt + deficit + gdp_head + realgdpgr +  
    inflation + cs1 + cs2 + cabinet_econ + (1 | countryn) + (1 |  
    govern) + (1 | year)
   Data: libdata_73_92
REML criterion at convergence: 1630.19
Random effects:
 Groups   Name        Std.Dev.
 govern   (Intercept) 1.29024 
 countryn (Intercept) 0.39761 
 year     (Intercept) 0.09771 
 Residual             2.70969 
Number of obs: 312, groups:  govern, 129; countryn, 21; year, 20
Fixed Effects:
 (Intercept)      instcons         vturn      duration    succession         openc  
  -1.300e+02    -1.066e-01     2.855e-02     7.252e-04     1.808e-01    -4.591e-02  
       unemp       elderly      deindust            ud          debt       deficit  
   1.820e-02     9.533e-02     8.907e-02    -6.536e-03     3.616e-02     1.457e-01  
    gdp_head     realgdpgr     inflation           cs1           cs2  cabinet_econ  
  -2.411e-01    -8.795e-03     1.759e-01     6.447e-02     3.721e-01    -2.984e-02  

NOTE: Log Print Time:  2023-06-05 23:27:48.811668 
NOTE: Elapsed Time: 0.162356853485107 secs 

Linear mixed model fit by REML ['lmerModLmerTest']
Formula: delib ~ instcons + vturn + duration + succession + openc + unemp +  
    elderly + deindust + ud + debt + deficit + gdp_head + realgdpgr +  
    inflation + cs1 + cs2 + gov_left + (1 | countryn) + (1 |      govern) + (1 | year)
   Data: libdata_73_92
REML criterion at convergence: 1396.697
Random effects:
 Groups   Name        Std.Dev.
 govern   (Intercept) 0.5576  
 countryn (Intercept) 0.6489  
 year     (Intercept) 0.2638  
 Residual             1.8588  
Number of obs: 312, groups:  govern, 129; countryn, 21; year, 20
Fixed Effects:
(Intercept)     instcons        vturn     duration   succession        openc  
  1.795e+02    5.656e-02   -4.471e-02   -1.667e-04   -5.567e-01   -9.908e-03  
      unemp      elderly     deindust           ud         debt      deficit  
  1.842e-02    6.255e-02    1.902e-02   -1.301e-02    1.458e-02    3.100e-02  
   gdp_head    realgdpgr    inflation          cs1          cs2     gov_left  
 -7.969e-02    1.810e-03    8.103e-02   -8.809e-02    1.160e-01    7.497e-04  

NOTE: Log Print Time:  2023-06-05 23:27:53.404082 
NOTE: Elapsed Time: 4.59241414070129 secs 

Linear mixed model fit by REML ['lmerModLmerTest']
Formula: delib ~ instcons + vturn + duration + succession + openc + unemp +  
    elderly + deindust + ud + debt + deficit + gdp_head + realgdpgr +  
    inflation + cs1 + cs2 + soci + (1 | countryn) + (1 | govern) +      (1 | year)
   Data: libdata_73_92
REML criterion at convergence: 1387.695
Random effects:
 Groups   Name        Std.Dev.
 govern   (Intercept) 0.5562  
 countryn (Intercept) 0.6524  
 year     (Intercept) 0.2620  
 Residual             1.8591  
Number of obs: 312, groups:  govern, 129; countryn, 21; year, 20
Fixed Effects:
(Intercept)     instcons        vturn     duration   succession        openc  
  1.819e+02    5.495e-02   -4.426e-02   -1.644e-04   -5.555e-01   -9.895e-03  
      unemp      elderly     deindust           ud         debt      deficit  
  1.950e-02    6.421e-02    1.882e-02   -1.302e-02    1.438e-02    3.067e-02  
   gdp_head    realgdpgr    inflation          cs1          cs2         soci  
 -7.895e-02    1.379e-03    8.084e-02   -8.930e-02    1.175e-01    3.706e-02  

NOTE: Log Print Time:  2023-06-05 23:27:53.571414 
NOTE: Elapsed Time: 0.16733193397522 secs 

Linear mixed model fit by REML ['lmerModLmerTest']
Formula: delib ~ instcons + vturn + duration + succession + openc + unemp +  
    elderly + deindust + ud + debt + deficit + gdp_head + realgdpgr +  
    inflation + cs1 + cs2 + chri + (1 | countryn) + (1 | govern) +      (1 | year)
   Data: libdata_73_92
REML criterion at convergence: 1384.886
Random effects:
 Groups   Name        Std.Dev.
 govern   (Intercept) 0.5418  
 countryn (Intercept) 0.6647  
 year     (Intercept) 0.2585  
 Residual             1.8553  
Number of obs: 312, groups:  govern, 129; countryn, 21; year, 20
Fixed Effects:
(Intercept)     instcons        vturn     duration   succession        openc  
  1.662e+02    4.042e-02   -4.744e-02   -1.851e-04   -4.694e-01   -1.220e-02  
      unemp      elderly     deindust           ud         debt      deficit  
  1.697e-02    6.043e-02    3.301e-02   -1.077e-02    1.160e-02    3.395e-02  
   gdp_head    realgdpgr    inflation          cs1          cs2         chri  
 -9.616e-02    1.474e-03    7.941e-02   -8.143e-02    1.059e-01    7.519e-01  
fit warnings:
Some predictor variables are on very different scales: consider rescaling

NOTE: Log Print Time:  2023-06-05 23:27:53.736509 
NOTE: Elapsed Time: 0.165095090866089 secs 

Linear mixed model fit by REML ['lmerModLmerTest']
Formula: delib ~ instcons + vturn + duration + succession + openc + unemp +  
    elderly + deindust + ud + debt + deficit + gdp_head + realgdpgr +  
    inflation + cs1 + cs2 + cabinet_econ + (1 | countryn) + (1 |  
    govern) + (1 | year)
   Data: libdata_73_92
REML criterion at convergence: 1394.912
Random effects:
 Groups   Name        Std.Dev.
 govern   (Intercept) 0.5568  
 countryn (Intercept) 0.6415  
 year     (Intercept) 0.2590  
 Residual             1.8599  
Number of obs: 312, groups:  govern, 129; countryn, 21; year, 20
Fixed Effects:
 (Intercept)      instcons         vturn      duration    succession         openc  
   1.738e+02     5.635e-02    -4.279e-02    -1.606e-04    -5.532e-01    -9.921e-03  
       unemp       elderly      deindust            ud          debt       deficit  
   1.805e-02     6.657e-02     2.007e-02    -1.317e-02     1.430e-02     3.267e-02  
    gdp_head     realgdpgr     inflation           cs1           cs2  cabinet_econ  
  -8.254e-02     9.644e-04     8.123e-02    -8.526e-02     1.149e-01    -2.153e-03  

NOTE: Log Print Time:  2023-06-05 23:27:53.918365 
NOTE: Elapsed Time: 0.181855916976929 secs 

Linear mixed model fit by REML ['lmerModLmerTest']
Formula: lib ~ instcons + vturn + duration + succession + openc + unemp +  
    elderly + deindust + ud + debt + deficit + gdp_head + realgdpgr +  
    inflation + cs1 + cs2 + gov_left + (1 | countryn) + (1 |      govern) + (1 | year)
   Data: libdata_93_12
REML criterion at convergence: 2110.054
Random effects:
 Groups   Name        Std.Dev.
 govern   (Intercept) 0.9965  
 countryn (Intercept) 1.4527  
 year     (Intercept) 0.6065  
 Residual             3.3823  
Number of obs: 378, groups:  govern, 139; countryn, 23; year, 19
Fixed Effects:
(Intercept)     instcons        vturn     duration   succession        openc  
 -2.052e+04   -5.818e-01    3.014e-03    1.523e-03   -1.518e+00   -6.204e-03  
      unemp      elderly     deindust           ud         debt      deficit  
  2.780e-01    3.463e-01   -4.976e-02   -1.056e-02    1.329e-02    1.174e-01  
   gdp_head    realgdpgr    inflation          cs1          cs2     gov_left  
  1.466e-02   -3.185e-01   -8.616e-02    1.034e+01   -7.041e+00   -1.521e-02  
optimizer (nloptwrap) convergence code: 0 (OK) ; 0 optimizer warnings; 2 lme4 warnings 

NOTE: Log Print Time:  2023-06-05 23:27:58.469197 
NOTE: Elapsed Time: 4.55083203315735 secs 

Linear mixed model fit by REML ['lmerModLmerTest']
Formula: lib ~ instcons + vturn + duration + succession + openc + unemp +  
    elderly + deindust + ud + debt + deficit + gdp_head + realgdpgr +  
    inflation + cs1 + cs2 + soci + (1 | countryn) + (1 | govern) +      (1 | year)
   Data: libdata_93_12
REML criterion at convergence: 2100.572
Random effects:
 Groups   Name        Std.Dev.
 govern   (Intercept) 1.0017  
 countryn (Intercept) 1.4650  
 year     (Intercept) 0.5634  
 Residual             3.3822  
Number of obs: 378, groups:  govern, 139; countryn, 23; year, 19
Fixed Effects:
(Intercept)     instcons        vturn     duration   succession        openc  
 -1.900e+04   -5.507e-01   -2.912e-03    1.532e-03   -1.426e+00   -5.891e-03  
      unemp      elderly     deindust           ud         debt      deficit  
  2.696e-01    3.261e-01   -4.174e-02   -1.202e-02    1.438e-02    1.170e-01  
   gdp_head    realgdpgr    inflation          cs1          cs2         soci  
  6.848e-03   -3.143e-01   -7.189e-02    9.569e+00   -6.528e+00   -1.451e+00  
optimizer (nloptwrap) convergence code: 0 (OK) ; 0 optimizer warnings; 1 lme4 warnings 

NOTE: Log Print Time:  2023-06-05 23:27:58.630513 
NOTE: Elapsed Time: 0.16131591796875 secs 

Linear mixed model fit by REML ['lmerModLmerTest']
Formula: lib ~ instcons + vturn + duration + succession + openc + unemp +  
    elderly + deindust + ud + debt + deficit + gdp_head + realgdpgr +  
    inflation + cs1 + cs2 + chri + (1 | countryn) + (1 | govern) +      (1 | year)
   Data: libdata_93_12
REML criterion at convergence: 2105.296
Random effects:
 Groups   Name        Std.Dev.
 govern   (Intercept) 1.1532  
 countryn (Intercept) 1.5141  
 year     (Intercept) 0.6228  
 Residual             3.3709  
Number of obs: 378, groups:  govern, 139; countryn, 23; year, 19
Fixed Effects:
(Intercept)     instcons        vturn     duration   succession        openc  
 -1.598e+04   -4.747e-01    6.897e-03    1.512e-03   -1.700e+00   -4.170e-03  
      unemp      elderly     deindust           ud         debt      deficit  
  2.422e-01    3.114e-01   -4.352e-02   -1.344e-02    1.561e-02    1.095e-01  
   gdp_head    realgdpgr    inflation          cs1          cs2         chri  
  1.513e-02   -3.131e-01   -7.259e-02    8.048e+00   -5.508e+00   -7.808e-01  
fit warnings:
Some predictor variables are on very different scales: consider rescaling
optimizer (nloptwrap) convergence code: 0 (OK) ; 0 optimizer warnings; 1 lme4 warnings 

NOTE: Log Print Time:  2023-06-05 23:27:58.806178 
NOTE: Elapsed Time: 0.175665140151978 secs 

Linear mixed model fit by REML ['lmerModLmerTest']
Formula: lib ~ instcons + vturn + duration + succession + openc + unemp +  
    elderly + deindust + ud + debt + deficit + gdp_head + realgdpgr +  
    inflation + cs1 + cs2 + cabinet_econ + (1 | countryn) + (1 |  
    govern) + (1 | year)
   Data: libdata_93_12
REML criterion at convergence: 2111.529
Random effects:
 Groups   Name        Std.Dev.
 govern   (Intercept) 1.0822  
 countryn (Intercept) 1.5581  
 year     (Intercept) 0.5973  
 Residual             3.3763  
Number of obs: 378, groups:  govern, 139; countryn, 23; year, 19
Fixed Effects:
 (Intercept)      instcons         vturn      duration    succession         openc  
  -1.581e+04    -4.625e-01    -9.075e-03     1.451e-03    -1.473e+00    -6.292e-03  
       unemp       elderly      deindust            ud          debt       deficit  
   2.816e-01     2.477e-01    -3.794e-02    -1.146e-02     1.693e-02     1.331e-01  
    gdp_head     realgdpgr     inflation           cs1           cs2  cabinet_econ  
   2.167e-02    -3.172e-01    -5.142e-02     7.963e+00    -5.442e+00     2.973e-02  
optimizer (nloptwrap) convergence code: 0 (OK) ; 0 optimizer warnings; 2 lme4 warnings 

NOTE: Log Print Time:  2023-06-05 23:27:58.974028 
NOTE: Elapsed Time: 0.167850017547607 secs 

Linear mixed model fit by REML ['lmerModLmerTest']
Formula: delib ~ instcons + vturn + duration + succession + openc + unemp +  
    elderly + deindust + debt + deficit + gdp_head + realgdpgr +  
    inflation + cs1 + cs2 + gov_left + (1 | countryn) + (1 |      govern) + (1 | year)
   Data: libdata_93_12
REML criterion at convergence: 1856.569
Random effects:
 Groups   Name        Std.Dev. 
 govern   (Intercept) 0.4187423
 countryn (Intercept) 0.9624236
 year     (Intercept) 0.0005871
 Residual             2.2271276
Number of obs: 394, groups:  govern, 144; countryn, 23; year, 19
Fixed Effects:
(Intercept)     instcons        vturn     duration   succession        openc  
 -6.094e+03   -2.075e-02   -1.717e-02    1.002e-03   -6.677e-01    1.124e-03  
      unemp      elderly     deindust         debt      deficit     gdp_head  
 -1.095e-02   -3.790e-02    3.398e-03    8.488e-03   -3.559e-02   -3.802e-02  
  realgdpgr    inflation          cs1          cs2     gov_left  
 -2.650e-02    4.070e-02    3.070e+00   -2.038e+00    9.939e-03  
optimizer (nloptwrap) convergence code: 0 (OK) ; 0 optimizer warnings; 1 lme4 warnings 

NOTE: Log Print Time:  2023-06-05 23:28:03.871677 
NOTE: Elapsed Time: 4.89764881134033 secs 

Linear mixed model fit by REML ['lmerModLmerTest']
Formula: delib ~ instcons + vturn + duration + succession + openc + unemp +  
    elderly + deindust + ud + debt + deficit + gdp_head + realgdpgr +  
    inflation + cs1 + cs2 + soci + (1 | countryn) + (1 | govern) +      (1 | year)
   Data: libdata_93_12
REML criterion at convergence: 1774.528
Random effects:
 Groups   Name        Std.Dev. 
 govern   (Intercept) 0.6654860
 countryn (Intercept) 1.0138527
 year     (Intercept) 0.0002803
 Residual             2.1590534
Number of obs: 378, groups:  govern, 139; countryn, 23; year, 19
Fixed Effects:
(Intercept)     instcons        vturn     duration   succession        openc  
 -6.487e+03   -1.056e-01   -1.013e-02    9.566e-04   -8.130e-01    2.096e-03  
      unemp      elderly     deindust           ud         debt      deficit  
  1.075e-02   -6.965e-02    1.673e-02   -1.188e-02    1.180e-02   -3.640e-02  
   gdp_head    realgdpgr    inflation          cs1          cs2         soci  
 -3.200e-02   -2.828e-02    9.938e-02    3.267e+00   -2.161e+00    1.201e+00  
optimizer (nloptwrap) convergence code: 0 (OK) ; 0 optimizer warnings; 1 lme4 warnings 

NOTE: Log Print Time:  2023-06-05 23:28:04.045673 
NOTE: Elapsed Time: 0.173995971679688 secs 

Linear mixed model fit by REML ['lmerModLmerTest']
Formula: delib ~ instcons + vturn + duration + succession + openc + unemp +  
    elderly + deindust + debt + deficit + gdp_head + realgdpgr +  
    inflation + cs1 + cs2 + chri + (1 | countryn) + (1 | govern) +      (1 | year)
   Data: libdata_93_12
REML criterion at convergence: 1852.299
Random effects:
 Groups   Name        Std.Dev. 
 govern   (Intercept) 0.5697947
 countryn (Intercept) 0.9450707
 year     (Intercept) 0.0003524
 Residual             2.2221881
Number of obs: 394, groups:  govern, 144; countryn, 23; year, 19
Fixed Effects:
(Intercept)     instcons        vturn     duration   succession        openc  
 -7.214e+03   -2.902e-02   -1.399e-02    9.533e-04   -6.648e-01    2.039e-03  
      unemp      elderly     deindust         debt      deficit     gdp_head  
  2.028e-03    8.763e-03   -5.599e-03    6.899e-03   -3.273e-02   -3.694e-02  
  realgdpgr    inflation          cs1          cs2         chri  
 -2.664e-02    4.205e-02    3.634e+00   -2.419e+00   -7.236e-01  
fit warnings:
Some predictor variables are on very different scales: consider rescaling

NOTE: Log Print Time:  2023-06-05 23:28:04.246758 
NOTE: Elapsed Time: 0.201085090637207 secs 

Linear mixed model fit by REML ['lmerModLmerTest']
Formula: delib ~ instcons + vturn + duration + succession + openc + unemp +  
    elderly + deindust + debt + gdp_head + inflation + cs1 +  
    cs2 + cabinet_econ + (1 | countryn) + (1 | govern) + (1 |      year)
   Data: libdata_93_12
REML criterion at convergence: 1851.948
Random effects:
 Groups   Name        Std.Dev. 
 govern   (Intercept) 0.5745530
 countryn (Intercept) 0.8617444
 year     (Intercept) 0.0003914
 Residual             2.2211143
Number of obs: 394, groups:  govern, 144; countryn, 23; year, 19
Fixed Effects:
 (Intercept)      instcons         vturn      duration    succession         openc  
  -5.815e+03    -1.030e-01    -1.494e-02     1.020e-03    -7.699e-01     1.560e-03  
       unemp       elderly      deindust          debt      gdp_head     inflation  
   9.728e-03     2.181e-02     5.019e-03     6.913e-03    -5.275e-02     2.150e-02  
         cs1           cs2  cabinet_econ  
   2.930e+00    -1.938e+00    -1.760e-02  
optimizer (nloptwrap) convergence code: 0 (OK) ; 0 optimizer warnings; 1 lme4 warnings 

NOTE: Log Print Time:  2023-06-05 23:28:04.408754 
NOTE: Elapsed Time: 0.161996126174927 secs 

Linear mixed model fit by REML ['lmerModLmerTest']
Formula: delib ~ instcons + vturn + duration + succession + openc + unemp +  
    elderly + deindust + debt + deficit + gdp_head + realgdpgr +  
    inflation + cs1 + cs2 + cons + (1 | countryn) + (1 | govern) +      (1 | year)
   Data: libdata_93_12
REML criterion at convergence: 1850.427
Random effects:
 Groups   Name        Std.Dev. 
 govern   (Intercept) 0.4113597
 countryn (Intercept) 1.0975669
 year     (Intercept) 0.0006605
 Residual             2.2279336
Number of obs: 394, groups:  govern, 144; countryn, 23; year, 19
Fixed Effects:
(Intercept)     instcons        vturn     duration   succession        openc  
 -7.858e+03   -1.021e-01   -1.609e-02    1.008e-03   -6.094e-01   -8.948e-04  
      unemp      elderly     deindust         debt      deficit     gdp_head  
 -7.693e-04   -4.146e-02   -5.920e-03    7.106e-03   -3.842e-02   -3.271e-02  
  realgdpgr    inflation          cs1          cs2         cons  
 -2.922e-02    3.508e-02    3.959e+00   -2.631e+00   -8.368e-01  
optimizer (nloptwrap) convergence code: 0 (OK) ; 0 optimizer warnings; 2 lme4 warnings 

NOTE: Log Print Time:  2023-06-05 23:28:09.37613 
NOTE: Elapsed Time: 4.96737599372864 secs 

Linear mixed model fit by REML ['lmerModLmerTest']
Formula: libtax ~ instcons + vturn + duration + succession + openc + unemp +  
    elderly + deindust + ud + debt + deficit + gdp_head + realgdpgr +  
    inflation + cs1 + cs2 + gov_left + (1 | countryn) + (1 |      govern) + (1 | year)
   Data: libdata
REML criterion at convergence: 1050.45
Random effects:
 Groups   Name        Std.Dev.
 govern   (Intercept) 0.10100 
 year     (Intercept) 0.07763 
 countryn (Intercept) 0.25230 
 Residual             0.81363 
Number of obs: 372, groups:  govern, 192; year, 39; countryn, 23
Fixed Effects:
(Intercept)     instcons        vturn     duration   succession        openc  
  2.194e+01    4.787e-02   -1.830e-03   -8.239e-05    1.711e-01   -1.925e-03  
      unemp      elderly     deindust           ud         debt      deficit  
 -2.489e-03    2.779e-03   -5.183e-03   -2.093e-03    1.068e-03    2.502e-02  
   gdp_head    realgdpgr    inflation          cs1          cs2     gov_left  
  1.096e-02    4.428e-02    2.123e-02   -1.068e-02    1.042e-02   -2.305e-03  

NOTE: Log Print Time:  2023-06-05 23:28:10.845307 
NOTE: Elapsed Time: 1.46917700767517 secs 

Linear mixed model fit by REML ['lmerModLmerTest']
Formula: libtax ~ instcons + vturn + duration + succession + openc + unemp +  
    elderly + deindust + ud + debt + deficit + gdp_head + realgdpgr +  
    inflation + cs1 + cs2 + cabinet_econ + (1 | countryn) + (1 |  
    govern) + (1 | year)
   Data: libdata
REML criterion at convergence: 1051.342
Random effects:
 Groups   Name        Std.Dev.
 govern   (Intercept) 0.08153 
 year     (Intercept) 0.06336 
 countryn (Intercept) 0.24257 
 Residual             0.82097 
Number of obs: 372, groups:  govern, 192; year, 39; countryn, 23
Fixed Effects:
 (Intercept)      instcons         vturn      duration    succession         openc  
  12.1196679     0.0571826    -0.0011116    -0.0000753     0.1594798    -0.0020702  
       unemp       elderly      deindust            ud          debt       deficit  
  -0.0034682    -0.0099851    -0.0033730    -0.0015111     0.0016357     0.0235737  
    gdp_head     realgdpgr     inflation           cs1           cs2  cabinet_econ  
   0.0118446     0.0440531     0.0217130    -0.0057639     0.0065723    -0.0017530  

NOTE: Log Print Time:  2023-06-05 23:28:11.047143 
NOTE: Elapsed Time: 0.201835870742798 secs 

Linear mixed model fit by REML ['lmerModLmerTest']
Formula: libtax ~ instcons + vturn + duration + succession + openc + unemp +  
    elderly + deindust + ud + debt + deficit + gdp_head + realgdpgr +  
    inflation + cs1 + cs2 + soci + (1 | countryn) + (1 | govern) +      (1 | year)
   Data: libdata
REML criterion at convergence: 1042.273
Random effects:
 Groups   Name        Std.Dev.
 govern   (Intercept) 0.11466 
 year     (Intercept) 0.06969 
 countryn (Intercept) 0.25941 
 Residual             0.81311 
Number of obs: 372, groups:  govern, 192; year, 39; countryn, 23
Fixed Effects:
(Intercept)     instcons        vturn     duration   succession        openc  
  1.705e+01    5.190e-02   -2.358e-03   -7.657e-05    1.754e-01   -1.876e-03  
      unemp      elderly     deindust           ud         debt      deficit  
 -5.159e-03   -1.377e-03   -5.142e-03   -2.161e-03    1.325e-03    2.446e-02  
   gdp_head    realgdpgr    inflation          cs1          cs2         soci  
  9.994e-03    4.450e-02    2.151e-02   -8.172e-03    8.713e-03   -1.828e-01  

NOTE: Log Print Time:  2023-06-05 23:28:11.233821 
NOTE: Elapsed Time: 0.186677932739258 secs 

Linear mixed model fit by REML ['lmerModLmerTest']
Formula: libtax ~ instcons + vturn + duration + succession + openc + unemp +  
    elderly + deindust + ud + debt + deficit + gdp_head + realgdpgr +  
    inflation + cs1 + cs2 + chri + (1 | countryn) + (1 | govern) +      (1 | year)
   Data: libdata
REML criterion at convergence: 1043.568
Random effects:
 Groups   Name        Std.Dev.
 govern   (Intercept) 0.09617 
 year     (Intercept) 0.06026 
 countryn (Intercept) 0.24253 
 Residual             0.82003 
Number of obs: 372, groups:  govern, 192; year, 39; countryn, 23
Fixed Effects:
(Intercept)     instcons        vturn     duration   succession        openc  
 15.9874256    0.0605904   -0.0019526   -0.0000837    0.1619672   -0.0019851  
      unemp      elderly     deindust           ud         debt      deficit  
 -0.0030002   -0.0110461   -0.0038409   -0.0016295    0.0016420    0.0242383  
   gdp_head    realgdpgr    inflation          cs1          cs2         chri  
  0.0122535    0.0432809    0.0221244   -0.0077053    0.0075609   -0.0222320  
fit warnings:
Some predictor variables are on very different scales: consider rescaling

NOTE: Log Print Time:  2023-06-05 23:28:11.411412 
NOTE: Elapsed Time: 0.17759108543396 secs 

Linear mixed model fit by REML ['lmerModLmerTest']
Formula: libepl ~ instcons + vturn + duration + succession + openc + unemp +  
    elderly + deindust + ud + debt + deficit + gdp_head + realgdpgr +  
    inflation + cs1 + cs2 + gov_left + (1 | countryn) + (1 |      govern) + (1 | year)
   Data: libdata
REML criterion at convergence: 1149.547
Random effects:
 Groups   Name        Std.Dev.
 govern   (Intercept) 0.5104  
 year     (Intercept) 0.2844  
 countryn (Intercept) 0.2796  
 Residual             1.7654  
Number of obs: 260, groups:  govern, 150; year, 38; countryn, 22
Fixed Effects:
(Intercept)     instcons        vturn     duration   succession        openc  
 -8.8313296   -0.2453180    0.0067619   -0.0001254   -0.2065827   -0.0058944  
      unemp      elderly     deindust           ud         debt      deficit  
  0.1358905    0.0323324   -0.0670197   -0.0109726    0.0123128    0.0951082  
   gdp_head    realgdpgr    inflation          cs1          cs2     gov_left  
  0.1032963   -0.0696149    0.0153282    0.0053734   -0.0257389    0.0014208  

NOTE: Log Print Time:  2023-06-05 23:28:16.754403 
NOTE: Elapsed Time: 5.34299111366272 secs 

Linear mixed model fit by REML ['lmerModLmerTest']
Formula: libepl ~ instcons + vturn + duration + succession + openc + unemp +  
    elderly + deindust + ud + debt + deficit + gdp_head + realgdpgr +  
    inflation + cs1 + cs2 + cabinet_econ + (1 | countryn) + (1 |  
    govern) + (1 | year)
   Data: libdata
REML criterion at convergence: 1147.049
Random effects:
 Groups   Name        Std.Dev.
 govern   (Intercept) 0.5079  
 year     (Intercept) 0.2925  
 countryn (Intercept) 0.2251  
 Residual             1.7663  
Number of obs: 260, groups:  govern, 150; year, 38; countryn, 22
Fixed Effects:
 (Intercept)      instcons         vturn      duration    succession         openc  
   5.9872896    -0.2250823     0.0034472    -0.0001722    -0.1857439    -0.0062925  
       unemp       elderly      deindust            ud          debt       deficit  
   0.1382939     0.0279583    -0.0638385    -0.0109061     0.0119127     0.0995138  
    gdp_head     realgdpgr     inflation           cs1           cs2  cabinet_econ  
   0.1008425    -0.0646743     0.0181287    -0.0021831    -0.0197237     0.0078429  

NOTE: Log Print Time:  2023-06-05 23:28:16.946608 
NOTE: Elapsed Time: 0.19220495223999 secs 

Linear mixed model fit by REML ['lmerModLmerTest']
Formula: libepl ~ instcons + vturn + duration + succession + openc + unemp +  
    elderly + deindust + ud + debt + deficit + gdp_head + realgdpgr +  
    inflation + cs1 + cs2 + soci + (1 | countryn) + (1 | govern) +      (1 | year)
   Data: libdata
REML criterion at convergence: 1140.449
Random effects:
 Groups   Name        Std.Dev.
 govern   (Intercept) 0.5082  
 year     (Intercept) 0.2787  
 countryn (Intercept) 0.2582  
 Residual             1.7679  
Number of obs: 260, groups:  govern, 150; year, 38; countryn, 22
Fixed Effects:
(Intercept)     instcons        vturn     duration   succession        openc  
 -6.9978511   -0.2468407    0.0074810   -0.0001311   -0.2167714   -0.0058271  
      unemp      elderly     deindust           ud         debt      deficit  
  0.1374793    0.0373482   -0.0675290   -0.0109458    0.0122059    0.0959703  
   gdp_head    realgdpgr    inflation          cs1          cs2         soci  
  0.1046655   -0.0724827    0.0137960    0.0043955   -0.0258499    0.1527801  

NOTE: Log Print Time:  2023-06-05 23:28:17.117255 
NOTE: Elapsed Time: 0.170646905899048 secs 

Linear mixed model fit by REML ['lmerModLmerTest']
Formula: libepl ~ instcons + vturn + duration + succession + openc + unemp +  
    elderly + deindust + ud + debt + deficit + gdp_head + realgdpgr +  
    inflation + cs1 + cs2 + chri + (1 | countryn) + (1 | govern) +      (1 | year)
   Data: libdata
REML criterion at convergence: 1137.363
Random effects:
 Groups   Name        Std.Dev.
 govern   (Intercept) 0.4540  
 year     (Intercept) 0.2874  
 countryn (Intercept) 0.2885  
 Residual             1.7692  
Number of obs: 260, groups:  govern, 150; year, 38; countryn, 22
Fixed Effects:
(Intercept)     instcons        vturn     duration   succession        openc  
 -2.267e+01   -1.941e-01    1.409e-02   -1.098e-04   -2.776e-01   -4.431e-03  
      unemp      elderly     deindust           ud         debt      deficit  
  1.261e-01    3.368e-02   -7.084e-02   -1.217e-02    1.243e-02    8.368e-02  
   gdp_head    realgdpgr    inflation          cs1          cs2         chri  
  1.012e-01   -6.849e-02    1.860e-02    1.228e-02   -3.280e-02   -7.977e-01  
fit warnings:
Some predictor variables are on very different scales: consider rescaling

NOTE: Log Print Time:  2023-06-05 23:28:17.275772 
NOTE: Elapsed Time: 0.158517122268677 secs 

Linear mixed model fit by REML ['lmerModLmerTest']
Formula: libneb ~ instcons + vturn + duration + succession + openc + unemp +  
    elderly + deindust + ud + debt + deficit + gdp_head + realgdpgr +  
    inflation + cs1 + cs2 + gov_left + (1 | countryn) + (1 |      govern) + (1 | year)
   Data: libdata
REML criterion at convergence: 1035.189
Random effects:
 Groups   Name        Std.Dev.
 govern   (Intercept) 0.2770  
 year     (Intercept) 0.1653  
 countryn (Intercept) 0.1443  
 Residual             0.7464  
Number of obs: 376, groups:  govern, 199; year, 39; countryn, 23
Fixed Effects:
(Intercept)     instcons        vturn     duration   succession        openc  
 -2.496e+01   -1.084e-01    1.543e-03    1.373e-04   -3.983e-02   -2.327e-03  
      unemp      elderly     deindust           ud         debt      deficit  
  5.523e-02    6.025e-02    3.741e-03    3.155e-04    1.584e-04    1.292e-02  
   gdp_head    realgdpgr    inflation          cs1          cs2     gov_left  
  2.120e-02   -2.148e-02   -5.461e-03    1.204e-02   -1.684e-02   -2.217e-03  

NOTE: Log Print Time:  2023-06-05 23:28:21.661026 
NOTE: Elapsed Time: 4.38525390625 secs 

Linear mixed model fit by REML ['lmerModLmerTest']
Formula: libneb ~ vturn + duration + succession + openc + unemp + elderly +  
    deindust + ud + debt + deficit + gdp_head + realgdpgr + inflation +  
    cs1 + cs2 + cabinet_econ + (1 | countryn) + (1 | govern) +      (1 | year)
   Data: libdata
REML criterion at convergence: 1024.077
Random effects:
 Groups   Name        Std.Dev.
 govern   (Intercept) 0.26653 
 year     (Intercept) 0.16982 
 countryn (Intercept) 0.08224 
 Residual             0.74571 
Number of obs: 376, groups:  govern, 199; year, 39; countryn, 23
Fixed Effects:
 (Intercept)         vturn      duration    succession         openc         unemp  
  -2.068e+01    -3.489e-03     1.209e-04    -4.385e-02    -2.576e-03     5.369e-02  
     elderly      deindust            ud          debt       deficit      gdp_head  
   2.980e-02     7.942e-03     2.439e-03     1.372e-04     1.360e-02     1.878e-02  
   realgdpgr     inflation           cs1           cs2  cabinet_econ  
  -2.176e-02     6.786e-03     9.692e-03    -1.544e-02     1.174e-02  

NOTE: Log Print Time:  2023-06-05 23:28:21.849686 
NOTE: Elapsed Time: 0.188659906387329 secs 

Linear mixed model fit by REML ['lmerModLmerTest']
Formula: libneb ~ instcons + vturn + duration + succession + openc + unemp +  
    elderly + deindust + ud + debt + deficit + gdp_head + realgdpgr +  
    inflation + cs1 + cs2 + soci + (1 | countryn) + (1 | govern) +      (1 | year)
   Data: libdata
REML criterion at convergence: 1024.444
Random effects:
 Groups   Name        Std.Dev.
 govern   (Intercept) 0.2644  
 year     (Intercept) 0.1644  
 countryn (Intercept) 0.1554  
 Residual             0.7473  
Number of obs: 376, groups:  govern, 199; year, 39; countryn, 23
Fixed Effects:
(Intercept)     instcons        vturn     duration   succession        openc  
 -2.948e+01   -1.074e-01    9.022e-04    1.444e-04   -2.579e-02   -2.377e-03  
      unemp      elderly     deindust           ud         debt      deficit  
  5.364e-02    5.842e-02    3.762e-03    2.140e-04    2.461e-04    1.239e-02  
   gdp_head    realgdpgr    inflation          cs1          cs2         soci  
  2.004e-02   -2.002e-02   -3.573e-03    1.437e-02   -1.777e-02   -2.560e-01  

NOTE: Log Print Time:  2023-06-05 23:28:22.027639 
NOTE: Elapsed Time: 0.177953004837036 secs 

Linear mixed model fit by REML ['lmerModLmerTest']
Formula: libneb ~ instcons + vturn + duration + succession + openc + unemp +  
    elderly + deindust + ud + debt + deficit + gdp_head + realgdpgr +  
    inflation + cs1 + cs2 + chri + (1 | countryn) + (1 | govern) +      (1 | year)
   Data: libdata
REML criterion at convergence: 1027.695
Random effects:
 Groups   Name        Std.Dev.
 govern   (Intercept) 0.2958  
 year     (Intercept) 0.1672  
 countryn (Intercept) 0.1430  
 Residual             0.7437  
Number of obs: 376, groups:  govern, 199; year, 39; countryn, 23
Fixed Effects:
(Intercept)     instcons        vturn     duration   succession        openc  
 -2.742e+01   -1.026e-01    3.490e-04    1.357e-04   -4.044e-02   -2.400e-03  
      unemp      elderly     deindust           ud         debt      deficit  
  5.281e-02    4.760e-02    6.026e-03    7.300e-04    5.256e-04    1.285e-02  
   gdp_head    realgdpgr    inflation          cs1          cs2         chri  
  2.082e-02   -2.482e-02   -4.981e-03    1.330e-02   -1.848e-02    1.134e-01  
fit warnings:
Some predictor variables are on very different scales: consider rescaling

NOTE: Log Print Time:  2023-06-05 23:28:22.219873 
NOTE: Elapsed Time: 0.192234039306641 secs 

Linear mixed model fit by REML ['lmerModLmerTest']
Formula: delibpri ~ instcons + vturn + duration + succession + openc +  
    unemp + elderly + deindust + ud + debt + deficit + gdp_head +  
    realgdpgr + inflation + cs1 + cs2 + gov_left + (1 | countryn) +  
    (1 | govern) + (1 | year)
   Data: libdata
REML criterion at convergence: 437.9329
Random effects:
 Groups   Name        Std.Dev.
 govern   (Intercept) 0.4697  
 year     (Intercept) 0.8012  
 countryn (Intercept) 0.2007  
 Residual             0.1845  
Number of obs: 212, groups:  govern, 125; year, 38; countryn, 22
Fixed Effects:
(Intercept)     instcons        vturn     duration   succession        openc  
  1.964e+02    8.895e-02   -9.037e-03   -3.727e-05   -1.683e-01   -3.520e-03  
      unemp      elderly     deindust           ud         debt      deficit  
 -1.067e-02   -1.169e-01    2.053e-02    1.058e-03    4.140e-03   -2.275e-02  
   gdp_head    realgdpgr    inflation          cs1          cs2     gov_left  
 -1.133e-02   -1.029e-02    2.848e-02   -9.854e-02    1.059e-01    1.604e-03  

NOTE: Log Print Time:  2023-06-05 23:28:27.114431 
NOTE: Elapsed Time: 4.89455795288086 secs 

Linear mixed model fit by REML ['lmerModLmerTest']
Formula: delibpri ~ instcons + vturn + duration + succession + openc +  
    unemp + elderly + deindust + ud + debt + deficit + gdp_head +  
    realgdpgr + inflation + cs1 + cs2 + cabinet_econ + (1 | countryn) +  
    (1 | govern) + (1 | year)
   Data: libdata
REML criterion at convergence: 435.5516
Random effects:
 Groups   Name        Std.Dev.
 govern   (Intercept) 0.4722  
 year     (Intercept) 0.8076  
 countryn (Intercept) 0.1415  
 Residual             0.1865  
Number of obs: 212, groups:  govern, 125; year, 38; countryn, 22
Fixed Effects:
 (Intercept)      instcons         vturn      duration    succession         openc  
   1.836e+02     8.076e-02    -7.516e-03    -2.338e-05    -1.717e-01    -2.881e-03  
       unemp       elderly      deindust            ud          debt       deficit  
  -1.132e-02    -1.043e-01     2.192e-02     9.428e-04     3.688e-03    -2.324e-02  
    gdp_head     realgdpgr     inflation           cs1           cs2  cabinet_econ  
  -1.103e-02    -9.589e-03     2.838e-02    -9.208e-02     9.928e-02    -5.100e-03  

NOTE: Log Print Time:  2023-06-05 23:28:27.302033 
NOTE: Elapsed Time: 0.187602043151855 secs 

Linear mixed model fit by REML ['lmerModLmerTest']
Formula: delibpri ~ instcons + vturn + duration + succession + openc +  
    unemp + elderly + deindust + ud + debt + deficit + gdp_head +  
    realgdpgr + inflation + cs1 + cs2 + soci + (1 | countryn) +  
    (1 | govern) + (1 | year)
   Data: libdata
REML criterion at convergence: 428.5987
Random effects:
 Groups   Name        Std.Dev.
 govern   (Intercept) 0.4692  
 year     (Intercept) 0.7985  
 countryn (Intercept) 0.2129  
 Residual             0.1837  
Number of obs: 212, groups:  govern, 125; year, 38; countryn, 22
Fixed Effects:
(Intercept)     instcons        vturn     duration   succession        openc  
  2.017e+02    9.134e-02   -8.925e-03   -4.615e-05   -1.751e-01   -3.711e-03  
      unemp      elderly     deindust           ud         debt      deficit  
 -9.611e-03   -1.171e-01    2.036e-02    1.288e-03    4.131e-03   -2.308e-02  
   gdp_head    realgdpgr    inflation          cs1          cs2         soci  
 -1.012e-02   -1.044e-02    2.753e-02   -1.012e-01    1.074e-01    1.653e-01  

NOTE: Log Print Time:  2023-06-05 23:28:27.498312 
NOTE: Elapsed Time: 0.196279048919678 secs 

Linear mixed model fit by REML ['lmerModLmerTest']
Formula: delibpri ~ instcons + vturn + duration + succession + openc +  
    unemp + elderly + deindust + ud + debt + deficit + gdp_head +  
    realgdpgr + inflation + cs1 + cs2 + chri + (1 | countryn) +  
    (1 | govern) + (1 | year)
   Data: libdata
REML criterion at convergence: 428.7383
Random effects:
 Groups   Name        Std.Dev.
 govern   (Intercept) 0.4654  
 year     (Intercept) 0.8022  
 countryn (Intercept) 0.2279  
 Residual             0.1854  
Number of obs: 212, groups:  govern, 125; year, 38; countryn, 22
Fixed Effects:
(Intercept)     instcons        vturn     duration   succession        openc  
  1.905e+02    9.709e-02   -7.984e-03   -3.614e-05   -1.718e-01   -3.516e-03  
      unemp      elderly     deindust           ud         debt      deficit  
 -1.051e-02   -1.120e-01    1.891e-02    9.822e-04    4.030e-03   -2.356e-02  
   gdp_head    realgdpgr    inflation          cs1          cs2         chri  
 -1.285e-02   -1.067e-02    3.023e-02   -9.551e-02    1.039e-01   -1.527e-01  
fit warnings:
Some predictor variables are on very different scales: consider rescaling

NOTE: Log Print Time:  2023-06-05 23:28:27.747544 
NOTE: Elapsed Time: 0.249232053756714 secs 

========================================================================= 
Log End Time: 2023-06-05 23:28:32.150793 
Log Elapsed Time: 0 00:01:02 
========================================================================= 
